AutoExtinguish: true — synthesizes length-safe constant-time comparison primitives and verifies compilation + tests in the 4-Gate sandbox.
Commercial boundary: ciphermap immunity scan, immunity extinguish --apply, immunity attest (CycloneDX 1.6 CISA IBOM & OpenVEX 0.2.0), and ciphermap mcp require Tier B Enterprise Fleet. Offline proof and IBOM verification (--verify-proof, attest --verify) and the ciphermap demo sandbox run Free.
Non-Constant-Time Secret, HMAC, or Webhook Signature Comparison
Severity: HIGH
Standard string and byte-slice equality operators short-circuit on the first mismatched byte, creating an observable statistical timing side-channel over network or local IPC boundaries when validating webhook signatures, HMAC digests, or API tokens. CipherMap IMM-TIMING-001 traces cryptographic digest and secret identifiers across all 12 supported languages and synthesizes constant-time equality replacements verified inside the 4-Gate OS sandbox.
Remediation checklist
- Go: replace == / bytes.Equal on digests and secrets with crypto/hmac.Equal or crypto/subtle.ConstantTimeCompare; Python: replace == with hmac.compare_digest.
- TypeScript & JavaScript: verify buffer byte lengths match first, then compare with node:crypto.timingSafeEqual; Java & Kotlin: use MessageDigest.isEqual on raw digest bytes.
- C#: use CryptographicOperations.FixedTimeEquals; Rust: use subtle::ConstantTimeEq; Ruby: ActiveSupport::SecurityUtils.secure_compare; PHP: hash_equals.
Illustrative Code Examples
These fragments explain migration direction. They are not complete applications or compiler-verified patches for your project.
Vulnerable — short-circuiting string equality on webhook HMAC digest
// Go: leaks prefix match length via early-exit string comparison
expected := hex.EncodeToString(mac.Sum(nil))
if signatureHeader == expected {
processWebhook(payload)
}Remediated — constant-time comparison (4-Gate verified)
// Go: constant-time comparison over decoded or byte digests
expected := hex.EncodeToString(mac.Sum(nil))
if subtle.ConstantTimeCompare([]byte(signatureHeader), []byte(expected)) == 1 {
processWebhook(payload)
}Scan your own repository for IMM-TIMING-001 locally (0 code egress)
Preview proposed changes free with ciphermap fix . --dry-run --offline --no-telemetry. Eligibility depends on the installed build, call shape, module format, and migration context. The bundled RSA fixture has a classical key-size candidate; that does not make it post-quantum secure. Persisted digests and unsupported contexts may be declined. Applying supported candidates requires an entitlement, explicit verifier consent, and the required project tools. Review the actual verification result before adopting a change.
Other rule families
Quantum-Vulnerable Public Key (RSA / DSA / DH)
PQC-GO-AST-003Quantum-Vulnerable Elliptic Curves (ECC) & Pre-Standard PQC Drafts
PQC-GO-AST-001Deprecated & Broken Cryptographic Primitives
IMM-SQLI-001Dynamic SQL String Interpolation or Concatenation Across Polyglot Drivers
IMM-PATH-001Unjailed Filesystem Path Traversal or Symlink Escape Across Polyglot I/O
IMM-CMD-001Dynamic Shell Command Execution Across Polyglot Process APIs
IMM-BOUND-001Unbounded Stream or Payload Allocation Across Polyglot Boundaries
IMM-DESER-001Unsafe Polymorphic Deserialization or Permissive Boundary Decoding
IMM-AUTH-001Unauthenticated or Unguarded State-Mutating Boundary Endpoint
IMM-JWT-001Unverified JWT Signature Decoding Before Claims Trust
IMM-SSRF-001Unvalidated Server-Side Request Forgery (SSRF) & Cloud IMDS Exposure
IMM-AICFG-001AI Coding Agent Instruction & MCP Configuration Poisoning
IMM-CSPRNG-001Weak Non-Cryptographic PRNG in Security Token, OTP, or Secret Generation
IMM-REDIR-001Unvalidated Open Redirect from Raw HTTP Parameter
PQC-COOKIE-4KPQC Wire-Size Rollout Cliffs: 4KB Cookies, SQL VARCHAR(255) & HTTP 431 Headers
PQC-FED-001NSA CNSA 2.0 Category-5 Floor, PIV/CAC & Firmware Signatures
PQC-BANK-002Banking TR-31/TR-34 Key Blocks, Mainframe ICSF & Open Banking FAPI 2.0
PQC-IAM-001Identity (OIDC / SAML / FIDO2 WebAuthn) & Cloud KMS Envelope Keys
PQC-OT-001OT/ICS OPC UA, IEC 62443 Secure Boot & Healthcare DICOM/HL7 FHIR